Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lulu Fraser's avatar

This is a really important passage to read from the brilliant Robert Hubbell. Yes, long. But, it is important to know that Democrats are letting us down. They voted to keep the trains running for an autocracy. Chuck Schumer is not the leader for the moment. I encourage folks to read this to better understand what happened with the CR vote yesterday. If this passage resonates with you, please let your senators and Chuck Schumer know what you think and why. Thank you.

"Democrats made a deal with Senate Republicans to split the DHS funding bill from five other bills and agreed to a two-week continuing resolution to fund DHS. Although there may be a brief shutdown because of the need to recall the House into session, the deal has Trump’s approval. See Politico, Trump-blessed deal to keep government funded gets snagged in Senate.

The net effect of the deal is to keep the government open by passing 11 of the 12 bills necessary to fund the 2026-27 budget. That leaves only the funding for DHS on the table. Democrats hope to use the next two weeks to pressure Republicans to agree to substantial reforms to DHS and ICE. See NPR, How Democrats want to reform DHS — and why some Republicans are open to their demands.

Here is the short version of what happened: Democrats had significant leverage because they could shut down 6 of 12 agencies to force Republicans to reform ICE. By agreeing to pass 5 of those bills, Democrats have given away most of their leverage to force ICE reform. Their only leverage will be the threat to withhold funding from DHS.

It is possible that a continuing DHS shutdown will be enough of a threat to force Republicans to agree to meaningful reforms at ICE. That strategy will work only if the seven Democratic senators who capitulated to Trump last November hold firm this time.

I am skeptical that Democrats have the courage and discipline to hold out indefinitely on a DHS shutdown. I hope I am wrong.

But beyond my skepticism and hope is a more important issue: People are dying in the streets as part of a massive, peaceful, effective resistance to ICE. Senate Democrats could have taken a bold stand in solidarity with Americans who are risking their lives to defend democracy. Instead, Democrats are working with Republicans to keep the trains running on time for a lawless regime.

It would have been better if Senate Democrats had shown fire in the belly and solidarity with people in the streets. Instead, they let a moment of great leverage slip out of their hands because they were caught in the technicalities of passing legislation.

Chuck Schumer appears to have no idea what is happening in the streets across the nation. If he did, he would have explained to the millions of Americans risking their lives why this deal is the best way forward. Not in a press release; not in a leak to Axios or the WSJ; and not in a stiff, by-the-book explanation of the legislative process with tired, partisan jabs at Republicans.

People are dying, Chuck. For you. For your liberties. For your state. For a Congress that refuses to do its job. They are putting their lives on the line in the hope that Congress will rouse itself to act like the first branch of government and come to the aid of the Constitution.

We need someone in the Senate who can be our voice, our inspiration, our comforter, and our fellow foot soldier in peaceful protest and civil disobedience. That’s not Chuck Schumer. It is incumbent on every Senate Democrat to fix the leadership problem in the caucus, ASAP. The best solution would be for Schumer to recognize that he is not the leader we deserve in this moment and step aside. That would be a true act of leadership."

Robin Gilmartin's avatar

A tribute to Alex Pretti as a civil servant upholding the Oath to defend the Constitution. We honor all those killed by agents and in detention today as we strike and boycott!

https://rgilmartin.substack.com/p/a-picture-of-a-civil-servant

23 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?